You Can't Create Good Immigration Laws by Codging Together Half-Baked Ideas
Today’s Floor Play is a guest post by Melissa del Bosque
Republicans are finding out that creating immigration policy is harder
than they thought. It’s like playing whack-a-mole. You’ve got one
problem taken care of then another issue pops up. Here we are
two-and-half-months into the legislative session and Republican Rep.
Burt Solomons of Carrolton, author of the sanctuary city bill finally
got his legislation out of House committee today.
Every other bill that Governor Perry deemed a “legislative emergency”
has already flown through the Senate and is well on its way to passing
the House (or already passed). Perry’s already chose which pen he’ll
use to sign Voter ID, and the bill requiring women to get an invasive
ultrasound before they have an abortion. Ugh. It’s not been so easy
for Solomons’ HB 12, which allows police officers to ask for
citizenship status and prohibits any law enforcement agency from
stopping them. It also takes away state funding from any state agency
that doesn’t enforce federal immigration law.
The bill was primed to pass the House State Affairs committee last
week, when state Rep. Rene Oliveira, a Democrat from Brownsville,
pointed out that Solomons’ bill is so broadly written that it not only
affects law enforcement but also every school district in Texas.
Apparently, Solomons wasn’t aware that there’s a federal law Plyler v.
Doe that prohibits school officials from asking students’ citizenship
status. Whether legislators agree with the federal law or not,
Oliveira pointed out, “It’s the law of the land.”
Oliveira also made the cogent argument that HB 12 violates the Texas
Constitution, which guarantees every Texas child an education. Passing
the bill would put school districts in an untenable position: start
playing immigration officer or lose your state funding. And just to
make it even sweeter, get sued for violating federal law.
By yanking state funding, HB 12 would decimate communities, Oliveira
said. “It would mean that my school district in Brownsville would lose
$400 million of its $500 million budget. Not only is the bill
unconstitutional – it doesn’t make any sense to make teachers into
This gave Solomons’ some pause, while he thought it over. Republican
Rep. Byron Cook, chair of the House State Affairs committee, had the
good sense to hold off on taking a vote. Of course, good sense in the
Legislature is as fleeting as Rick Perry’s love for coyotes.
Today HB 12 got another airing — this time with a few minor
legislative tweaks from Solomons. Now teachers and other school
officials are exempted from the bill, a prudent move. But the bill
still includes law enforcement officers or security guards who work
for the school districts, which means cash-strapped school districts
are still going to get sued. Nevertheless, it seemed to be enough to
please the Republican majority on the committee who promptly passed
the bill. Solomons assured the doubting Democrats on the committee
that he wasn’t trying to tell school districts what to do. “I’m trying
to insure some clarity,” he said. But what Solomons is trying to fix
is about as clear as mud. Making meaningful immigration laws is
tedious, hard work. The Texas Legislature in its infinitiesimal wisdom
should slow ball HB 12 until Sine Die if they’ve got any sense at all.
Ultimately, it’s up to the federal government to fix this mess. They
got us into it. It’s their duty to get us out.