Librotraficantes Fight Attempt to Whitewash History in Texas Universities

by Published on
Tony Diaz and other 'Librotraficante' supporters
Patrick Michels
'Librotraficante' founder Tony Diaz at the Capitol Thursday.

A year ago, Houston-based writer Tony Diaz led the Librotraficante bus tour to Tucson, “smuggling” books back into a state that had just effectively banned Mexican-American studies classes in public schools.

This morning Diaz was on a similar mission, but much closer to home—outside the third-floor Capitol office of Houston Republican Sen. Dan Patrick, who filed a proposal last week to only count “comprehensive survey” courses toward undergraduate history requirements. Students interested in Latino, African-American, LGBT or women’s history, for instance, wouldn’t be able to count those classes against the requirement.

Those implications weren’t lost on the crowd of university students and activists waiting around to speak with Patrick’s staff—just days, coincidentally, after a federal judge upheld Arizona’s law. ”It’s the same target group, except it’s a different approach” under Patrick’s bill, Diaz explained. “It seems like Senator Patrick is auditioning to be the next Jan Brewer.”

Patrick’s bill (and a House companion by Southlake freshman Rep. Giovanni Capriglione) are the legislative response to a recent report from the New York-based National Association of Scholarspromoted by Austin’s own Texas Public Policy Foundation—claiming that the University of Texas and Texas A&M over-emphasize niche history courses at the expense of American and Western tradition. While the report may have come from New York, our own Bill Minutaglio noted another local connection: it was funded in part by D magazine publisher Wick Allison.

The report, “Recasting History: Are Race, Class and Gender Dominating American History?” answers that question for readers after just two paragraphs. In a neat trick, its list of recommendations closes with, “10. Depoliticize history.”

High time these academics quit thinking about history and just start teaching it. Surely there’s a dominant historical narrative to keep us all happy enough.

“There is an agenda to remove dozens of books out of the curriculum at a time,” Diaz said this morning. ”In a global economy, why would you want to build a border wall around American history?”

The bills have been referred to higher education committees in their respective chambers; neither has been scheduled for a hearing yet.

Patrick Michels is a reporter for the Texas Observer and a former legislative intern. He has been a staff writer and web editor at the Dallas Observer, and a former editor of the Texas Independent. He has a bachelor's in journalism from Northwestern University, a master's in photojournalism from the University of Texas at Austin, and is a competitive eating enthusiast.

  • http://www.facebook.com/stan.buchanan.54 Stan Buchanan

    Does the s**t-storm ever stop in Texas? Even here in Indiana, the ignorant reactionaries, er, Republicans who dominate the legislature do take a breath occasionally. But now that Mike Pence, Rick Perry’s older, dumber brother, is governor of all Hoosiers, we’re bracing for a tsunami of roll-back-the-20th-Century legislation that could set records in dumb. So stand by.

  • Will

    What kills me Stan is their hypocrisy. This is the same bunch who screamed “local control” for years. Now, as with their testing regimens, they want to control curriculum and assessment with centralized authority.

  • http://twitter.com/PoisonOrRemedy MoshiMoshi

    You can’t expect to teach history to students that has so recently and so drastically affected their “station” in life. Depoliticization of history is like sex without the lubricant–it hurts! If the upper echelons are concerned about a class war manifesting from being historically aware of the past, they may as well stop celebrating the very Western 4th of July, President’s day Etc. to keep it “fair and balanced.”